Publication Search

66,773 articles from 556 journals · 1,699 citations tracked

Showing 81-100 of 156

Analytics

Andromeda Putri Herastita Anggipitasari; Larasati Widoningtyas

RISOMA : Jurnal Riset Sosial Humaniora dan Pendidikan 2025 Asosiasi Ilmuwan Pendidikan, Sosial, dan Humaniora Indonesia

This study aims to analyze the implementation of the Project Based Learning (PjBL) model in enhancing students' creativity in Social Studies (IPS) learning for Grade VIII at SMP Negeri 3 Kedungwaru. The research method used is a qualitative approach with a case study design. Data collection techniques include observation, interviews, and documentation. The results show that the implementation of PjBL can enhance students' creativity through project activities that encourage critical thinking, collaboration, and problem-solving. Students become more active, confident in expressing ideas, and capable of producing innovative work. Despite several challenges such as limited time and varied student participation, PjBL has proven to be effective in creating contextual and meaningful learning.

Ari Deca Fitriani; Sigit Prasetyo

The purpose of this study is to analyze teachers’ understanding of authentic assessment. The assessment process seeks to evaluate whether educational goals have been met, thus highlighting the important role of evaluation in the education sector. Effective and comprehensive evaluation is conducted on an ongoing basis, providing educators with a comprehensive view of student learning achievement and progress. Each subject emphasizes the importance of ongoing assessment, which is aligned with broader educational goals and outcomes. This article serves as a literature review intended to explore the features of 21st century learning and their implications for assessment, specifically authentic assessment. Given globalization and rapid technological advancements, the educational paradigm has shifted from a teacher-centered approach to a student-centered approach. Learning in the 21st century prioritizes the enhancement of critical thinking, creativity, collaboration, and communication skills (often referred to as the 4Cs). Therefore, conventional assessment is considered inadequate to measure learning outcomes that are complex and contextual. This study explores various relevant scientific sources to formulate a comprehensive understanding of authentic assessment as an approach that is in line with the characteristics of 21st century learning. Authentic assessment emphasizes real, contextual processes and products, and provides meaningful learning experiences. The findings of this study recommend that teachers need to design assessments that are integrated with the learning process, encourage active student involvement, and assess abilities holistically. This study is expected to be a guide for education professionals in creating assessment methods that are in line with 21st century requirements.

Aulia Yurniati; Natasya Yulindra Putri; Salwa Sausan; Ari Suriani

RISOMA : Jurnal Riset Sosial Humaniora dan Pendidikan 2025 Asosiasi Ilmuwan Pendidikan, Sosial, dan Humaniora Indonesia

Indonesia's Golden Vision 2045 demands the readiness of superior, creative, and adaptive human resources in the face of rapid digital technological advancements. Digital literacy is one of the primary foundations that must be instilled from an early age, particularly at the elementary school level. This article aims to comprehensively examine the importance of digital literacy at the elementary school level, its role in shaping 21st-century character and skills, and the challenges and strategies for its implementation in elementary education. Through a literature review method, this article analyzes various research findings and best practices related to strengthening digital literacy in elementary school-aged children.The results show that digital literacy not only enhances students' technical skills in operating digital devices but also fosters critical thinking, creativity, collaboration, and effective communication. Additionally, digital literacy plays a crucial role in building digital ethics awareness and cybersecurity, as well as promoting reading interest through interactive learning media. However, challenges persist, including limited facilities, uneven teacher competence, and a lack of integration of digital literacy in the curriculum. To overcome these obstacles, synergy is needed between schools, governments, and communities in providing infrastructure, teacher training, and developing relevant curricula.Thus, strengthening digital literacy from elementary school is a strategic step in preparing a smart, critical, and competitive generation, while supporting the achievement of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and Indonesia's Golden Vision 2045.

Faris Azzam Husain; Nur Kamaluddin akhmad; Mohammad Syaifuddin

Akhlak : Jurnal Pendidikan Agama Islam dan Filsafat 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Agama dan Filsafat Indonesia

The learning strategy of Islamic Religious Education (PAI) plays a crucial role in shaping students' character and morality, especially in addressing educational challenges in the era of Generation Alpha. This generation, born amid rapid technological advancement, tends to be fast-thinking, visual, and practical, yet is also vulnerable to moral crises and ethical degradation. This study aims to describe and analyze the PAI learning strategies implemented at MTs Ma’arif NU Sragi in shaping the noble character and morals of students. The research employs a descriptive qualitative approach with data collection techniques including observation, in-depth interviews, and documentation. The findings reveal that the applied learning strategies include project-based religious learning, internalization of values through teacher role modeling, utilization of Islamic digital media, and contextual learning relevant to students' daily lives. These strategies have proven effective in instilling values of religiosity, discipline, responsibility, and honesty. The success of these strategies is supported by a religious school environment, active teacher involvement, and parental support. Challenges encountered include limited technological facilities and the pervasive negative influence of social media. This study recommends the reinforcement of collaboration among teachers, parents, and educational institutions to optimize the role of PAI in developing the character of future generations.

Awalina Barokah; Titin Sunaryati; Yossi Srianita; Dinda Tri Oktavia

Jurnal Pengabdian Masyarakat 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

This community service activity aims to optimize the strengthening of teachers' soft skills through the implementation of the Pancasila Student Profile Strengthening Project (P5) based on scientific literacy. Soft skills such as communication, collaboration, critical thinking, and leadership are essential competencies for teachers in creating meaningful and transformative learning. This activity was carried out in several public elementary schools in Bekasi City with a participatory training approach and direct practice-based mentoring. The training materials were designed to integrate scientific literacy with Pancasila values ​​in the context of thematic learning. The results of the activity showed a significant increase in communication skills, collaboration skills, and teacher understanding in applying the dimensions of the Pancasila Student Profile into the learning process. In addition, this program also had a positive impact on shaping the professional behavior of teachers who were more reflective, collaborative, and oriented towards strengthening student character. These findings indicate that the integration of scientific literacy within the P5 framework can be an effective strategy in developing teachers' pedagogical competence.

Awalina Barokah; Titin Sunaryati; Yossi Srianita; Dinda Tri Oktavia

Jurnal Pengabdian Masyarakat 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

This community service activity aims to optimize the strengthening of teachers' soft skills through the implementation of the Pancasila Student Profile Strengthening Project (P5) based on scientific literacy. Soft skills such as communication, collaboration, critical thinking, and leadership are essential competencies for teachers in creating meaningful and transformative learning. This activity was carried out in several public elementary schools in Bekasi City with a participatory training approach and direct practice-based mentoring. The training materials were designed to integrate scientific literacy with Pancasila values ​​in the context of thematic learning. The results of the activity showed a significant increase in communication skills, collaboration skills, and teacher understanding in applying the dimensions of the Pancasila Student Profile into the learning process. In addition, this program also had a positive impact on shaping the professional behavior of teachers who were more reflective, collaborative, and oriented towards strengthening student character. These findings indicate that the integration of scientific literacy within the P5 framework can be an effective strategy in developing teachers' pedagogical competence.

Devi Supriani; Aser Yalindua; Caroline Manuahe

Jurnal Pendidikan Kimia, Fisika dan Biologi 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Indonesia

Critical thinking skills are an important competency in learning biology, especially in biodiversity materials that require analysis, reasoning, and decision-making. This study aims to determine the influence of the Guided Discovery Learning learning model  on the critical thinking ability of grade X students at SMA Negeri 2 Tondano. The method used was a quasi-experimental study with a pretest-posttest control group design. The sample consisted of two classes, namely the control class that was taught using the conventional model and the experimental class that received treatment with the Guided Discovery Learning model. Data were collected through pretest and posttest written tests, and analyzed using normality, homogeneity, and t-test. The results showed that there was a significant difference between the learning outcomes of students in the experimental class and the control class. The average posttest score of the experimental class was 81 higher than the control class of 63.5. In addition, the Tcal value of 4.65 is greater than the Ttable of 2.02 at a significance level of 0.05, which shows that  the Guided Discovery Learning model  has a positive influence on improving students' critical thinking skills. This result is also strengthened by a decrease in standard deviation which shows an equal distribution of understanding between students. This research contributes to the development of active learning strategies in biology education and suggests the application of this model to improve higher-level thinking skills. This model is also relevant applied to other topics in order to strengthen discovery-based learning and collaboration.

Sakdiyah Sakdiyah; Widna Widna; Gusmaneli Gusmaneli

Dinamika Pembelajaran : Jurnal Pendidikan dan bahasa 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

This study aims to analyze the integration of technology in Islamic Religious Education (IRE) as a strategic effort to develop students’ 21st-century skills, particularly the 4Cs: Critical Thinking, Creativity, Communication, and Collaboration. In the digital era, educators are required to adapt learning approaches that not only convey religious knowledge but also empower students with relevant skills for navigating modern challenges. Employing a qualitative research method through a comprehensive literature review, this study explores various scholarly works that discuss the role of digital technology in supporting the development of 21st-century competencies within the IRE framework. The analysis reveals that technology-enhanced IRE learning fosters student engagement, strengthens critical and creative thinking processes, facilitates interactive communication, and encourages collaborative learning environments. Furthermore, the integration of technology allows for the contextualization of Islamic values in formats that resonate with the current digital-native generation. This synergy between religious instruction and digital innovation supports the holistic development of learners, ensuring they are intellectually equipped and spiritually grounded. The findings highlight the necessity for educators to design innovative, flexible, and value-based learning strategies that align with technological advancements while preserving the core principles of Islamic education. Ultimately, this research offers valuable insights for practitioners, policymakers, and curriculum developers in enhancing the relevance and effectiveness of Islamic Religious Education in the 21st century.

Anita Puspa Meilina

Jurnal Manajemen dan Pendidikan Agama Islam 2025 Asosiasi Riset Pendidikan Agama dan Filsafat Indonesia

The urgency to strengthen the pedagogical competence of Islamic Elementary Teacher Education (PGMI) teachers has increased in line with 21st-century learning demands, which emphasize critical thinking, collaboration, and meaningful learning. However, in practice, many PGMI teachers still face significant gaps in understanding and applying constructivist approaches effectively. This article aims to analyze these gaps and evaluate the potential for developing pedagogical competencies within the framework of constructivist theory. This study adopts a qualitative approach using library research methods, gathering secondary data from scholarly literature, educational policies, and previous relevant studies. Data analysis was conducted through content analysis, applying the Miles and Huberman model. The findings reveal a persistent reliance on conventional teaching methods, limited pedagogical literacy regarding constructivism, and insufficient integration of theory into teacher education curricula and training. The study concludes that systemic reforms are required in curriculum design, teacher training, and institutional partnerships to bridge these pedagogical gaps. This article contributes both conceptually and practically to the development of constructivist-based learning models in Islamic elementary education. Field-based follow-up research is recommended to empirically strengthen these findings.

Marwan Marwan; Deviyantoro Deviyantoro

International Journal of Management 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Manajemen Kewirausahaan dan Bisnis Indonesia

This study investigates the dual impact of teacher competence on student academic performance and the development of leadership qualities in Senior High Schools and Vocational High Schools in Kabupaten Serang, Banten Province. Using a qualitative research approach, data were collected through interviews, focus groups, and classroom observations involving teachers and students. The findings reveal that teacher competence encompasses not only mastery of subject matter and pedagogical skills but also emotional intelligence and leadership modeling. Competent teachers create supportive and participatory learning environments that enhance both academic achievement and leadership development among students. The research highlights that effective teachers are those who not only deliver content but also engage students in meaningful ways, fostering a sense of belonging and motivation. This engagement is crucial, as it encourages students to take ownership of their learning and develop critical thinking skills. Furthermore, the study identifies that teachers who model leadership behaviors—such as ethical decision-making, effective communication, and collaboration—significantly influence students' perceptions of leadership and their willingness to adopt similar traits. However, challenges such as limited access to professional development and resource constraints affect the full realization of teacher competence. Many teachers express a desire for ongoing training and support to enhance their skills, yet systemic barriers often hinder their professional growth. The study underscores the need for comprehensive teacher development programs and policy support to improve educational outcomes holistically. These insights are valuable for educators, policymakers, and school administrators aiming to foster academic excellence and leadership skills in students. By prioritizing teacher competence and providing the necessary resources, schools can create an environment that not only promotes academic success but also prepares students to become effective leaders in their communities. 

Tiarma Rokasih Sagala; Mirna Putri Aulia; Sri Rahma Haryanti; M. Joharis

International Journal of Educational Development 2025 Asosiasi Periset Bahasa Sastra Indonesia

This study aims to comprehensively examine the influence of the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) model integrated with the Internet of Things (IoT) on enhancing students’ problem-solving abilities in physics education. The integration of IoT into PBL is seen as a progressive approach to address the growing demand for innovative instructional strategies that promote higher-order thinking skills. A quantitative approach was adopted, utilizing a quasi-experimental design with a pretest-posttest nonequivalent control group format to assess the effectiveness of the intervention. The participants were 25 undergraduate physics students from the University of West Sulawesi, selected through saturated sampling due to the limited population size. To evaluate students’ problem-solving skills, data were collected using structured written tests designed around five key indicators: understanding the problem, describing the problem, planning the solution, executing the solution, and evaluating the results. Prior to hypothesis testing, normality of the data was assessed using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, followed by paired sample t-tests with IBM SPSS Statistics 23 to determine the significance of differences in pretest and posttest scores. The findings revealed a statistically significant improvement in students’ problem-solving skills following the implementation of the IoT-based PBL model, with results showing significance at the 5% level and gain scores classified as effective. These outcomes demonstrate the potential of the PBL-IoT integration to foster critical thinking and improve educational quality. Therefore, the implementation of this instructional model is recommended for physics educators seeking to enhance student engagement, problem-solving proficiency, and learning outcomes through the integration of emerging technologies.    

Renda Pandu Winata; M. Syahran Jailani

Jurnal Bintang Pendidikan Indonesia 2025 Pusat Riset dan Inovasi Nasional

This study is based on the importance of Mathematics Learning based on Computational Thinking in Asy-Syifa Islamic Schools, Jambi City, because some students at Asy-Syifa Islamic Schools, Jambi City have difficulty understanding the concept of learning mathematics, lack of practice, and even motivation factors. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to determine the planning, implementation and evaluation of Mathematics Learning Based on Computational Thinking in the Era of Independent Learning Curriculum in class IV of Asy-Syifa Islamic School, Jambi City. To achieve these goals, the researcher used qualitative research with the method used Phenomenology. The data collection techniques used in this study were observation, interviews and documentation. The data source selected was snowball sampling using respondents from the principal, class IVA mathematics study teachers and class IV students. The data analysis techniques used in this study were data reduction, data presentation and data conclusions. The results of this study are 1) Planning of Mathematics Learning Based on Computational Thinking in the Era of Independent Learning Curriculum in grade IV of Asy-Syifa Islamic School, Jambi City includes Introduction to Computational Thinking, Determining learning objectives, Mathematics learning design based on Computational Thinking, Development of media or learning tools, Learning activities, Learning assessment and improvement. 2) Implementation of Mathematics Learning Based on Computational Thinking in the Era of Independent Learning Curriculum in grade IV of Asy-Syifa Islamic School, Jambi City includes Decomposition (Problem Deconstruction), Implementation of technology, Collaboration and Discussion and evaluation and reflection. 3) Evaluation of Mathematics Learning Based on Computational Thinking in the Era of Independent Learning Curriculum in grade IV of Asy-Syifa Islamic School, Jambi City includes Understanding the basic concept of Computational Thinking, Implementation in learning, Assessment of Computational Thinking skills, Learning outcomes and feedback from students and teachers.

Ary Wijaya; Nuril Huda; Muhajir Muhajir

International Journal of Education and Social Sciences 2025 International Forum of Researchers and Lecturers

Game-Based Learning (GBL) has emerged as an innovative learning approach aimed at enhancing student engagement and promoting the development of critical thinking skills, particularly at the elementary school level. This study was conducted at SD Negeri Labuhan 1 using a qualitative approach and a case study method. The primary objective of this research is to analyze the implementation of GBL within the context of elementary education, focusing on students’ and teachers’ needs and interests, the strategies used for implementation, the impact of GBL on students’ critical thinking skills, and the supporting and inhibiting factors affecting its success. The findings indicate that 75% of students expressed a higher preference for game-based learning over conventional teaching methods, showing high levels of enthusiasm and participation during the learning process. GBL proved effective in increasing students' motivation to learn, strengthening collaboration, and stimulating analytical and reflective thinking. However, several challenges were encountered in the implementation of GBL, including limited technological infrastructure in schools and the lack of specialized training for teachers in designing and managing game-based learning activities effectively. Based on these findings, it can be concluded that GBL holds significant potential as a teaching strategy that can foster students’ critical thinking skills from an early age. Nevertheless, to achieve optimal outcomes, strong support from various stakeholders is essential, including the provision of adequate facilities and the enhancement of teachers’ competencies through continuous professional development and training in designing and applying GBL in daily classroom activities.

Salman Shiddiq; Misra Misra

Concept: Journal of Social Humanities and Education 2025 Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Administrasi Yappi Makassar

Digital transformation has brought significant changes to education, revolutionizing the way knowledge is accessed, shared, and disseminated. It has provided a wealth of opportunities for innovation, convenience, and accessibility in learning. However, the rapid shift to digital platforms presents several challenges that may hinder the development of students’ critical thinking and exacerbate educational inequalities. Among these challenges are the digital divide, filter bubbles, and echo chambers, which can negatively impact students’ perspectives and deepen the educational gap between urban and rural areas. This research aims to analyze the effects of digital transformation on education, with a particular focus on Islamic education. It also explores the role of filter bubbles and echo chambers in shaping students' insights and understanding of various issues. The research method used is library research, involving the collection and analysis of literature from various scholarly sources such as Sinta, ResearchGate, and Google Scholar. The findings of the study highlight that digital transformation has facilitated the learning process through platforms like Google Classroom and Zoom, making education more accessible. However, it also introduces challenges, such as the spread of misinformation and hoaxes, which are amplified by filter bubbles and echo chambers. From an Islamic educational perspective, digital transformation aligns with the principles of seeking knowledge and justice. However, the digital divide contradicts the Islamic value of equal access to education for all. In conclusion, it is necessary to improve digital literacy, provide equitable infrastructure, and promote cross-perspective collaboration to create a more inclusive and equitable learning environment. The findings aim to guide policymakers and educators in shaping better educational strategies.

Nofamataro Zebua

Jurnal Ilmu Pendidikan 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

The transformation of education in the digital era demands a more innovative and adaptive approach to deal with the ever-evolving global dynamics. Deep Learning comes as a learning paradigm that emphasizes active student involvement in a meaningful, reflective, and fun learning process. Not only oriented towards knowledge transfer, this approach also accommodates the development of critical thinking, problem-solving, creativity, and collaboration skills, which are the main pillars of 21st-century competencies. This article explores the role of Deep Learning in shaping an educational ecosystem that is more responsive to change and discusses effective implementation strategies at various levels of learning. With the integration of cognitive, affective, and psychomotor aspects, this approach aims to create learning that is more contextual, adaptive, and transformative. Deep Learning not only encourages students to develop deeper conceptual understanding but also strengthens the connection between science and its application in real life. Through project-based methods, exploration, and utilization of digital technology, this approach opens up opportunities for the formation of an independent, innovative, and globally competitive generation.

Annisa Yulistya

Prosiding Seminar Nasional Ilmu Pendidikan 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Indonesia

The change from the Industrial Revolution 4.0 era to Society 5.0 has had a significant impact on education, especially through the use of technology in the learning process. The use of electronic modules, which combine text, audio, images, animation, and video, is one of the important innovations that supports 21st century learning with a focus on critical thinking, communication, collaboration, and creativity. This study uses bibliometric analysis to examine the trends and developments of electronic modules in economics learning from 2015 to 2024. The results of the study indicate that electronic modules increase students' independence and critical thinking skills and support more interactive and flexible learning. Bibliometric analysis conducted with VOSviewer identified research trends, topic relevance, and potential for further development. Electronic modules have proven to be an effective tool in digital education, although there are still some limitations in accessibility and interactivity. These findings emphasize the importance of innovation and continuous development of electronic modules in economics education to meet the needs of learning in the digital era.

Nofamataro Zebua

Jurnal Inovasi Pendidikan 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

The development of digital technology has brought significant changes in various aspects of life, including education. In biology learning, digital technology offers innovative solutions to overcome challenges in understanding abstract concepts, increase learning motivation, and develop 21st century skills. Interactive simulations, augmented reality (AR), virtual reality (VR) and online learning platforms allow students to visualize complex biological concepts, such as photosynthesis and DNA replication, more clearly and deeply. In addition, the integration of digital technology can improve students' critical thinking skills, creativity, collaboration and digital literacy. However, the implementation of digital technology in biology learning faces various challenges, including limited infrastructure, access gaps between urban and rural schools, and lack of training for educators. This study aims to explore the impact of digital technology on students' conceptual understanding and 21st century skills, and identify the main barriers to its implementation. The results of this study are expected to provide recommendations for the development of more effective and innovative biology learning strategies in the digital era

Wagiman Manik; Ahmad Sulaiman Siregar; Saiful Islam Abizar; Yudi Rahayu; Muhammad Iqbal +1 more

Reflection : Islamic Education Journal 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Agama dan Filsafat Indonesia

The 21st century is marked by the advancement of science and technology, driving increasingly complex changes in life. In the context of education, a multidisciplinary learning approach has become relevant in enhancing students' complex thinking abilities. This approach allows students to integrate various disciplines in solving existing problems, thereby improving their critical, analytical, and creative thinking skills. This study explores the relationship between multidisciplinary learning and students' complex thinking abilities, the factors influencing its implementation effectiveness, and effective multidisciplinary learning strategies. Based on previous research, multidisciplinary learning has been proven to enhance complex thinking skills by up to 35% compared to conventional learning methods. However, its implementation faces several challenges, including a lack of teacher readiness, limited resources, and a learning culture that still emphasizes rote memorization. Therefore, problem-based learning strategies, cross-disciplinary collaboration, and the use of technology are recommended to improve the effectiveness of this approach.

Nerita Setiyaningtiyas

International Journal of Christian Education and Philosophical Inquiry 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidkan Agama dan Filsafat Indonesia

The Industrial Revolution 4.0 has drastically changed the global employment landscape, necessitating the comprehensive development of 21st-century skills in education systems. This study examines how private high schools in Indonesia implement 21st-century skills, focusing on the barriers faced, the strategies used, and their impact on student learning outcomes. We used a mixed-methods approach involving 200 students, 25 teachers, and 10 principals from five private high schools in Java. Data were collected through surveys, semi-structured interviews, classroom observations, and document analysis. Quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics, while qualitative data were analyzed using thematic analysis. The results revealed four main barriers: limited teacher preparedness, limited resources, difficulties in assessment, and resistance to changes in teaching methods. Effective strategies implemented included ongoing professional development programs, integrating learning technology, project-based learning, and strengthening teacher collaboration. Our findings demonstrate significant improvements in students' critical thinking, creativity, collaboration, and communication skills in schools implementing the comprehensive strategy. This research provides theoretical contributions to understanding the implementation context in developing countries while offering practical implications for policy makers, school administrators, and educators in designing contextual and sustainable 21st-century skills development programs.

Laili Nazwa Adfiani; Dedi Masri; Muslem Muslem

Akhlak : Jurnal Pendidikan Agama Islam dan Filsafat 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Agama dan Filsafat Indonesia

This research was motivated by the researcher's interest in the efforts made by PAI teachers to develop students' critical thinking abilities so that students become more active in the learning process. This research uses qualitative methods with a type of field study (field research) through a descriptive qualitative approach. Data collection techniques use observation, interviews and documentation. The analysis was carried out according to experts, namely Milles and Hubberm, through data reduction, data presentation and drawing conclusions and researchers used triagulation as a form of checking the validity of the data obtained. The results of the research show that the critical thinking abilities of class VIII students at SMPN 40 Takengon are good, this can be seen when students are active in asking questions and fulfill the indicator criteria contained in critical thinking. Efforts made by PAI teachers to develop students' critical thinking skills include teachers asking students stimulating questions through a random system, secondly giving opportunities to students, thirdly using group/collaboration methods. Supporting factors for PAI teachers in developing critical thinking skills are cellphones, training/workshops, and teacher creativity. The inhibiting factors include limited time, different student abilities, creating a conducive atmosphere, and limited facilities and infrastructure.