Publication Search

80,088 articles from 759 journals · 2,111 citations tracked

Showing 21-40 of 215

Analytics

Ariedasita Calleza Aulia; Rahma Khoirun Nisa; Sharofina Putri Endiana; Endrise Septina Rawanoko

Jurnal Pendidikan dan Kewarganegara Indonesia 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Indonesia

This study aims to analyze the improvement of students’ knowledge and the alignment of the Civic Education learning model with the characteristics of third-grade students at SDN Kadipiro. The research problem arises from the tendency of Civic Education in elementary schools to rely heavily on lecture-based instruction, which results in low student engagement and limited comprehension of abstract concepts such as rights and obligations. A descriptive qualitative approach was employed through observations, interviews, and documentation to obtain a comprehensive picture of the learning process, the instructional model applied, and classroom dynamics. The findings reveal that the teacher implemented a game-based Discovery Learning model that emphasizes exploration, categorization, verification, and independent conclusion-making by students. This model proved effective, as evidenced by 85% of students being able to understand and distinguish examples of rights and obligations in accordance with the Civic Education learning outcomes. The study also indicates that game-based learning is more compatible with the students’ predominant visual and kinesthetic learning tendencies, enabling them to maintain focus more effectively than when using traditional lecture methods. However, several challenges emerged, including variations in students’ writing literacy skills and the absence of a structured assessment rubric. These findings underscore the need for flexible instructional design, the integration of concrete learning media, and the implementation of more systematic formative assessment practices. Future research is recommended to develop differentiated instructional strategies and to utilize more diverse media to accommodate the needs of heterogeneous classrooms.

Nur Aisyah; Nursamsi Nursamsi; Azwan Anwar

Jurnal Riset Rumpun Matematika dan Ilmu Pengetahuan Alam 2025 Pusat riset dan Inovasi Nasional

This research is a classroom action research (CAR) conducted at MA Darussalam with the aim of improving mathematics learning outcomes through the application of the Probing-Prompting model. The subjects of this study were 26 grade XII students. Data collection was carried out using learning outcome tests given before and after the application of the learning model. The collected data were analyzed quantitatively and qualitatively. The results showed that the average score of students' learning outcomes in cycle I reached 82.38, while in cycle II it increased to 86.15. Based on the learning outcome completion category used, the achievement of students' mathematics learning outcomes in cycle I was 73.07%, and in cycle II it reached 100%. The application of the Probing-Prompting model has proven effective in increasing students' motivation and understanding of the material being taught. Thus, it can be concluded that the use of the Probing-Prompting model has a positive effect on improving students' mathematics learning outcomes, showing a significant increase in their understanding and skills in solving mathematics problems.

Yaqin, Muhammad Ainul; Huda, Miftahul; Sholahuddin, Sholahuddin

Jurnal Kemitraan Masyarakat 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

The low effectiveness of student organizational performance in designing and managing structured work programs presents a major challenge to strengthening the leadership culture at MTsN 1 Probolinggo. This community service program aims to enhance students’ managerial and leadership capacities through performance mentoring for the Intra-Madrasah Student Organization (OSIM), based on innovations in learning management. The methods employed include training sessions, workshops, and continuous mentoring, all designed collaboratively with school stakeholders. The activity stages began with a needs analysis and problem mapping, followed by the development of training modules, the implementation of organizational management training, and interactive workshops aimed at developing adaptive and applicable work programs. The proposed solutions encompass strengthening foundational understanding of organizational management, enhancing the role of members in program planning, and facilitating the implementation of OSIM activities that support the creation of an active learning environment. Evaluation was carried out through pre-tests and post-tests to measure comprehension improvement, field activity observations, and assessments of work program achievement. The results indicate significant improvements in participants’ cognitive and practical skills, particularly in the planning, execution, and evaluation of OSIM programs that are now more structured and goal-oriented. In conclusion, this community service activity successfully reinforced student leadership competencies through an innovative approach to managing student organizations, while also promoting the development of a sustainable culture of collaborative work. Based on the outcomes, it is recommended that this mentoring model be replicated in other madrasahs and that OSIM leadership development programs be systematically integrated into extracurricular curricula to ensure the continuity and expansion of the positive impacts achieved

Fadlilah Al Hasanah; Kartika Manalu; Sayed Akhyar

Jurnal Pendidikan Dirgantara 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Indonesia

This research aims to determine the effect of learning using the Problem Based Learning model assisted by the Powtoon application on the learning outcomes of Class XI Madrasah Aliyah at the Islamic Education Park (TPI) Sawit Seberang. This research is a type of quantitative research with a Quasy Experimental Design. The research population was 36 students in class XI MIA A and 36 students in class XI MIA B, 36 students in class XI MIA C and 36 students in class, and X MIA C totaling 36 people as the control class. The instrument in this research is in the form of a test in the form of 30 multiple choice questions. Data analysis of student learning outcomes using the t-test formula, also with the help of SPSS version 25 data processing. Data analysis of student learning outcomes with the results of calculating the average learning outcomes shows that the experimental class which uses the Problem Based Learning models is higher than the control class. The prerequisite test is proven that the data is normally distributed and homogeneous. The results of the test calculation were obtained under count worth 9.709 and table worth 1.668 so that it shows tcount > table so Ha2 is accepted. The conclusions in this research explain that there are influences and differences before and after the implementation of the Problem Based Learning model on student learning outcomes in class XI Madrasah Aliyah at the Islamic Education Park (TPI) Sawit Seberang.

Durinda Puspasari; Durinta Puspasari; Ruri Nurul Aeni Wulandari; Lifa Farida Panduwinata; Andy Parsetyo Wati

International Journal of Studies in International Education 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Indonesia

This study focuses on the development of a case study–based digital book aimed at improving learning quality in Office Management education, where students are required to master both conceptual understanding and practical decision-making skills. Despite the increasing use of digital learning resources in higher education, existing instructional materials often lack contextual integration between theory and real workplace scenarios, resulting in limited student engagement and insufficient opportunities for problem-based learning. To address this issue, the present research aims to design and develop an interactive digital book enriched with authentic case studies that align with course learning outcomes. The study employed a Research and Development approach using the 4-D model Define, Design, and Develop to produce learning materials validated by experts and tested through limited trials. The results show that the digital book achieved high feasibility, with an average expert validation score of 87.33%, while student responses reached 93.87%, indicating strong acceptance, improved motivation, and enhanced perceived understanding. The synthesis of these findings demonstrates that embedding case-based learning elements into digital book formats can effectively support critical thinking, contextual reasoning, and independent learning in Office Management courses. In conclusion, the developed digital book is classified as highly feasible for instructional use and holds substantial potential to enhance learning experiences, although further research is recommended to examine its broader effectiveness and long-term impact on student learning outcomes.

Ibrahim Ibrahim; Febriansa Febriansa

International Journal of Education and Literature 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

The government has implemented various illiteracy eradication programs at both central and local levels. However, illiteracy remains high, with South Sulawesi ranking sixth nationally. This condition is influenced by the imbalance between the number of Non-Formal Education Units and target areas, limited human resources, as well as learner-related factors such as motivation, age, occupation, distance to learning sites, and monotonous teaching methods. Community learning services through literacy clinics using collaborative methods Reading, Writing Beginning, Structure, Analysis, and Synthesis, combined with project-based learning serve as alternative models to increase community participation and improve learning outcomes. The problem of this research is how the description of the implementation of basic literacy programs through the model "Community Learning Services Through Literacy Clinics"?, and how effective the model "Community Learning Services Through Literacy Clinics with the collaborative method approach?. The purpose of this study was to determine the description of the implementation model of basic literacy education programs and determine the effectiveness of learning outcomes. The results of the study illustrated that the basic literacy program was carried out in collaboration between the resources of the Non-formal Education Unit and the resources in the village/kelurahan government as the organizer and tutor Learning outcomes show that the Community Learning Service Model through the Literacy Clinic with a collaborative method approach was declared effective in improving student learning outcomes.

Maksimelianus Seran; Marsela Luruk Bere; Yanuarius Bria Seran; Damian Puling

Jurnal Pendidikan Dirgantara 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Indonesia

This study aims to determine the application of the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) model in improving Civic Education (PKn) learning outcomes among fourth-grade students at SDI Harekakae, Malaka Regency. This research employed an experimental method using a post-test only control group design. The population consisted of all fourth-grade students, with class IV B serving as the experimental group and class IV C as the control group, totaling 42 students. The experimental group was taught using the Problem-Based Learning model, while the control group was taught without applying the model. Data were collected through learning outcome tests, observations, and documentation. The results showed that the experimental class achieved an average score of 85 out of an ideal score of 100 with a standard deviation of 8.25, while the control class obtained an average score of 62.6. These findings indicate that the implementation of the Problem-Based Learning model significantly improves students’ Civic Education learning outcomes. Therefore, the Problem-Based Learning model is recommended as an innovative alternative to enhance the effectiveness of Civic Education learning in elementary schools.

Diah Haryati; Hanesman Hanesman

Uranus: Jurnal Ilmiah Teknik Elektro, Sains dan Informatika 2025 Asosiasi Riset Teknik Elektro dan Informatika Indonesia

The learning model that can be used to make students active is the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) model. The Problem-Based Learning model is a problem-based learning, where learning is centered on students so that students are required to provide solutions to the problems given. This study aims to determine how much impact the application of the PBL model has in improving student learning outcomes on learning the Basics of Electronic Engineering at SMK Negeri 2 Dumai. The type of research used is quantitative research with a quasi-experimental method using a pretest-posttest control group design. The research subjects consisted of 64 students divided into two groups, namely class X TEI SMK Negeri 2 Dumai as an experimental group that applies the PBL model (36 students) and class X TEI SMK Negeri 3 Dumai as a control group that applies the conventional learning model (28 students). The research instrument was a multiple-choice objective test of 25 items whose validity and reliability had been tested with a Cronbach's Alpha value of 0.843. The data analysis technique used descriptive statistics and Independent Samples T-Test. The results showed a significant difference in learning outcomes between the experimental and control classes, with a t-test value of 4.168 and a significance level of 0.000 (p < 0.05). The experimental class experienced an average increase in learning outcomes of 15.55 points (from 64.78 to 80.33), while the control class only increased by 7.57 points (from 63.43 to 71.00), with a posttest average difference of 9.333 points. Furthermore, the PBL model was also effective in reducing the ability gap between students, as indicated by a decrease in the standard deviation from 9.457 to 8.021. It can be concluded that the implementation of the PBL learning model has a significant impact on improving student learning outcomes in the Fundamentals of Electronic Engineering course at SMK Negeri 2 Dumai.

Saeful Fachri; Mila Nurmila; Emilia Sari; Rahmah Febriyanti; Intan Permatasari

Jurnal Pengabdian dan Pembangunan Lokal 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

The main problem faced by MA Al Ulya Al Mubarok is the low level of financial literacy and the lack of understanding of the importance of early investment. Most students still perceive saving as the only form of financial management without recognizing the potential for asset growth through safe and well-planned investments. The absence of practical education on personal financial management and limited access to learning resources about investment are the main barriers to developing intelligent and future-oriented financial behavior. As a solution, this community service program is designed to improve financial literacy and foster investment intention among students. The program will be implemented through several stages of activities, including: needs and baseline analysis of students, development of a contextual-based financial literacy module, interactive socialization and training on the basic concepts of saving, personal financial management, and introduction to investment. The expected outcomes of this program include: an increase in students’ financial literacy level by at least 30% based on pre-test and post-test results, the initiation of a student investment awareness community, and the creation of a financial literacy learning module that can be used sustainably by the school. This community service program is expected to serve as a model for financial literacy development in secondary education institutions while supporting national efforts to build a financially literate, independent, and future-oriented young generation.

Rahmi Putri; Marwah Hidayah; Gusmaneli Gusmaneli

Jurnal Manajemen dan Pendidikan Agama Islam 2025 Asosiasi Riset Pendidikan Agama dan Filsafat Indonesia

This study aims to describe the implementation of an active learning model based on collaboration to improve students’ conceptual understanding in Islamic Religious Education (PAI). The background of this research stems from the low level of student engagement in the learning process, which has resulted in less optimal understanding of religious concepts. The research employed a qualitative approach with a classroom action research (CAR) design conducted in two cycles. The subjects were eleventh-grade students at a senior high school in City X. Data were collected through observation, interviews, and conceptual understanding tests. The findings revealed that the implementation of the collaborative active learning model increased students’ participation in learning activities, fostered critical thinking skills, and enhanced their conceptual understanding of Islamic Education materials. Through group discussions, problem-solving activities, and reflection sessions, students became more cognitively and affectively engaged in the learning process. Therefore, the collaborative active learning model can serve as an effective alternative strategy to improve both the process and outcomes of Islamic Religious Education learning.

Merti Siska Rosely; Yandri Tuarissa; Hardjianti R. Jamadi

International Journal of Education and Literature 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

The era of globalization is an era of quality competition, where only thosebwith high competence will be able to compete in the free market. Therefore, developing high-quality human resources is something that cannot be compromised. Education that supports development in this era is education that can foster students’ potential’ enabling them toface and overcome life’s challenges. Thus, in the learning process, teachers should not only serve as models or sources of knowledge but also act as learning managers. As learning managers, teachers play an important role in creating a learning environment that allows students to learn confortably and effectively. Based on observations at SMA Negeri 2 Taniwel, it was found that students in class X-2 have low learning outcomes in sociology. The writer’s observation in class indicated that sociology learning was dominated by lecture methods, resulting in students being less active during the learning process. According to research conducted by Al Muchtar (1991), learning in social studies education does not sufficiently simulate students to be actively involved in the learning process. Furthermore, the teaching and learning process of social studies carried out bye teachers has not been able to faster a learning culture among students, wich in turn significantly affects their learning achievement and outcomes. To support active learning strategies, teachers can apply various relevant learning models. Therefore, the learning process will become more varied, innovative, and constructive, creating interaction between teachers and students, among students themselves, and between students and other learning resources.

Sabam Isay Sianipar; Putri Isnaini; Nazwa Azzahra; Cintya Agatha Rumahombar; Chelsea Natalia Panjaitan

Jurnal Riset Rumpun Matematika dan Ilmu Pengetahuan Alam 2025 Pusat riset dan Inovasi Nasional

This study aims to analyze the improvement of Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) through mathematics learning on the Three-Dimensional Geometry topic in Grade XII of Yayasan Pendidikan Al-Fattah Medan. HOTS is a crucial aspect of 21st-century education because it helps students develop critical, creative, logical, and reflective thinking skills in addressing complex problems. In the context of mathematics learning, particularly in spatial geometry, mastering HOTS not only supports students in understanding abstract concepts but also in applying them to real-life situations. This study employed a descriptive qualitative method with instruments consisting of a pre-test, post-test, and an open-ended questionnaire to explore students’ understanding and learning experiences. The findings revealed a significant improvement, where the average pre-test score of 7 increased to 52.21 in the post-test. This result highlights that the implementation of HOTS-based learning strategies is effective in enhancing students’ comprehension of distance, angles, and point positions in space, while simultaneously strengthening their analytical, evaluative, and creative abilities. The study implies the importance of adopting innovative learning strategies oriented toward HOTS development to improve the quality of mathematics education and prepare students for global challenges.

Sukwara Akfan, Sofyan

Jurnal Inovasi dan Pengabdian Kaa Mieera (JIPKAM) 2025 Politeknik Negeri Fakfak

This research aims to enhance students' English technical competence by implementing Problem-Based Learning (PBL) for the English for Mechanical Engineering course at Politeknik Negeri Fakfak. However, the setting of this research is rooted in students' difficulties in understanding technical terms and applying English in engineering work environments. Implementing a participatory action research model with descriptive qualitative approaches, the research was conducted among 50 students of two classes. Data were collected through questionnaires, observations, and interviews. The findings showed that 88% of students perceived the learning material as highly relevant, 84% reported improved mastery over technical vocabulary, and 90% reported greater collaboration and problem-solving skills. Furthermore, the intervention fostered active learning behaviors, peer leadership, and a positive shift towards more favorable attitudes among students towards English as a professional tool. These findings confirm that PBL is a valuable approach to English language learning contextualization in the vocational education context, enhancing the development of both language and soft skills. The research proposes wider implementation of PBL across technical curricula to improve educational outcomes in correspondence with industry requirements.

Firly Farziyah Nurfy; Siti Umi Khayatun Mardiyah

International Journal of Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Indonesia

This study investigates the implementation of the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) model integrated with animated video media to enhance student motivation, creativity, and learning outcomes in economics at MA Salafiyah. Employing a classroom action research approach with a pretest-posttest design, the research involved 35 grade XI students. Data were collected through observation sheets, motivation and creativity questionnaires, and learning outcome tests. The Shapiro-Wilk test was used to assess data normality, while the Wilcoxon Signed Rank Test evaluated the significance of differences between pretest and posttest scores. The findings reveal that the application of PBL with animated video media significantly improves student motivation, creativity, and learning outcomes. Students demonstrated increased engagement, generated more creative ideas, and showed deeper understanding of economic concepts. Motivation was reflected in higher posttest scores and active participation, while creativity was evident in the ability to propose innovative solutions and think critically. Learning outcomes improved substantially, with average scores rising from 46.142 (pretest) to 83.571 (posttest). The integration of animated video media in PBL created a dynamic and interactive learning environment that facilitated comprehension, stimulated interest, and encouraged practical application of knowledge. This study concludes that PBL supported by animated video media is an effective pedagogical strategy for improving educational quality in economics learning.

Putri Azizah Nasution; Rica Umrina Lubis; Lia Agustina Damanik

International Journal of Education and Literature 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

This study aims to improve student learning outcomes through the implementation of the Problem Based Learning (PBL) model assisted by PowerPoint media in Mathematics for Grade I students at SD IT Riyadhoturrohman. The research employs Classroom Action Research (CAR) conducted in two cycles. Each cycle consists of three meetings, following the stages of planning, implementation, observation, and reflection. The research subjects were 16 students from Grade I of SD IT Riyadhoturrohman. The Problem Based Learning model was chosen because it encouraged students to be actively involved in learning through solving contextual problems, while PowerPoint media was used to help visualize the mathematical concepts being taught. The results showed an improvement in students' learning outcomes from the pre-action stage to Cycle I, and a further increase in Cycle II. Additionally, students demonstrated improved participation, conceptual understanding, and teamwork skills. Thus, the implementation of the Problem Based Learning model assisted by PowerPoint media proved to be effective in improving the mathematics learning outcomes of Grade I students at SD IT Riyadhoturrohman.

Amalia Kusuma Dewi; Ernita Vika Aulia; Muhamad Arif Mahdiannur

Konstanta : Jurnal Matematika dan Ilmu Pengetahuan Alam 2025 International Forum of Researchers and Lecturers

The development of digital media and innovative learning models in Junior High School Science education reflects a sustained commitment to meeting the demands of 21st-century skills and improving the quality of science instruction. A comprehensive literature review (2019–2024) reveals the dominance of the Research and Development (R&D) approach, which consistently yields highly valid, practical, and effective digital resources, such as Augmented Reality (AR), Android-based applications, and interactive educational games. These digital tools are synergistically integrated with modern instructional models, including Problem-Based Learning (PBL), Inquiry-Based Learning (IBL), and Predict-Observe-Explain (POE), which are proven effective in increasing student engagement, enhancing cognitive outcomes, and honing essential competencies such as Science Process Skills (SPS) and Higher-Order Thinking Skills (HOTS). Ultimately, this integration contributes significantly to overcoming learning difficulties in complex and abstract Science topics (e.g., the human digestive system) while also effectively addressing contemporary educational challenges, fostering meaningful learning experiences, and supporting long-term academic success for students.

Rahmi Putri; Marwah Hidayah; Gusmaneli Gusmaneli

Hidayah : Cendekia Pendidikan Islam dan Hukum Syariah 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Agama dan Filsafat Indonesia

This study aims to describe the implementation of an active learning model based on collaboration to improve students’ conceptual understanding in Islamic Religious Education (PAI). The background of this research stems from the low level of student engagement in the learning process, which has resulted in less optimal understanding of religious concepts. The research employed a qualitative approach with a classroom action research (CAR) design conducted in two cycles. The subjects were eleventh-grade students at a senior high school in City X. Data were collected through observation, interviews, and conceptual understanding tests. The findings revealed that the implementation of the collaborative active learning model increased students’ participation in learning activities, fostered critical thinking skills, and enhanced their conceptual understanding of Islamic Education materials. Through group discussions, problem-solving activities, and reflection sessions, students became more cognitively and affectively engaged in the learning process. Therefore, the collaborative active learning model can serve as an effective alternative strategy to improve both the process and outcomes of Islamic Religious Education learning.

Limmey Maria Tambingon; Arrijani Arrijani; Musma Rukmana

Jurnal Cakrawala Pendidikan dan Biologi 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Indonesia

Biology education in high school has an important role in shaping students' science literacy and critical thinking skills. However, ecological material, particularly the topic of Ecosystem Components and their Interactions, is often considered difficult because it is abstract and not easy to observe directly. This research aims to improve student learning outcomes through the application of the Problem Based Learning (PBL) model, which emphasizes real problem-solving, collaborative discussion, and active involvement in the learning process. The research uses the design of Classroom Action Research (PTK) which was carried out in two cycles in class X of St. Rosa de Lima Catholic High School Tondano involving 10 students in the odd semester of the 2025/2026 school year. Data was collected through observation of teacher and student activities, learning outcome tests in the form of pretests and posttests, and learning documentation. The analysis was carried out descriptively, qualitatively, and quantitatively by calculating the average score, percentage of completion, and student involvement. The results of the study showed a significant increase. The percentage of teacher activity increased from 58.3% in the first cycle to 87.5% in the second cycle, while student activity increased from 45.83% to 83.33%. The average score of students also increased from 70% in cycle I to 90% in cycle II, with classical completeness reaching 90%. These findings confirm the effectiveness of PBL as a contextual Biology learning strategy, able to bridge ecological concepts with real life, and increase students' curiosity, cooperation, and critical thinking skills.

Nur Khasanah, Rahma; Kusumadani, Annur Indra; Mulyono, Yatin

JOURNAL OF BIOLOGY LEARNING 2025 Universitas Veteran Bangun Nusantara Sukoharjo

This study aims to analyze the application of SSPBLS (Socio-Scientific Problem based Learning with Spiritual Value) on digestive system materials at SMA Muhammadiyah 1 Sragen for the academic year 2024/2025 and to find out whether this model can improve student learning outcomes. The type of research used is quantitative with experimental design. Data collection was carried out through learning outcome tests, observations, and interviews. Based on the results of the t-test, a significance value (sig.) of 0.22 was obtained, which was more than 0.05, which showed that there was no significant difference between the experimental group using the SSPBLS model and the control group using conventional learning methods. The results of this study show that the application of the SSPBLS model to the digestive system material in terms of final average scores can improve student learning outcomes. These results show that SSPBLS has the potential to improve student understanding through a problem-based approach that connects scientific phenomena with social issues, and its application in the field has met expectations. This research contributes to enriching contextual learning approaches through the application of the SSPBLS model which is proven to improve student learning outcomes by integrating social issues, critical thinking skills, and character values and provides alternative effective learning strategies to improve learning outcomes, with an emphasis on students' active involvement in solving problems based on social issues.

Poppy Lariski; Siti Darwa Suryani; Kashardi Kashardi

International Journal of Educational Research 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Pendidikan Indonesia

This study aims to determine the effect of Problem Based Learning (PBL) and Inquiry learning models on students’critical thinking skills and cognitive learning outcomes on the topic of the human respiratory system. This research used a quasi-experimental design with a Non-Equivalent Pretest-Posttest Control Group Design. The research subjects were three eighth-grade classes at SMP Negeri 13 Lebong, consisting of two experimental classes taught using the PBL and Inquiry models and one control class using conventional methods. The research instruments included essay tests to measure critical thinking and multiple-choice tests to assess cognitive learning outcomes. Data were analyzed using ANOVA and LSD tests. The results showed significant differences among the three groups. The PBL model produced the highest improvement in both variables, followed by Inquiry, and lastly the control group. Therefore, PBL is proven to be the most Effective model inimproving students' critical thinking and cognitive learning outcomes in science education.