Publication Search

72,574 articles from 669 journals · 2,111 citations tracked

Showing 641-660 of 1,189

Analytics

Shannia Angelia Rahardjo; Muhamad Farudin

Mandub: Jurnal Politik, Sosial, Hukum dan Humaniora 2025 STAI YPIQ BAUBAU, SULAWESI TENGGARA

Infrastructure development has become a national priority to drive economic growth, with the KPBU (Public-Private Partnership) scheme as a solution to budget limitations. The transformation of PJPK (Project Implementing Agency) law in the latest regulations, including the authority of the Rector of State Universities with Legal Entity (PTN BH) and restrictions on the Board of Directors of Regional-Owned Enterprises (BUMD), demonstrates the policy dynamics that influence the effectiveness of infrastructure management based on KPBU in Indonesia. This research uses a normative juridical method with legislative and conceptual approaches to analyze regulations and legal theories related to the role of PJPK in KPBU. This approach aims to provide a strong argumentative foundation and a comprehensive analysis of the legal aspects in the implementation of infrastructure based on KPBU. This article emphasizes that the regulatory reform of the PJPK role in KPBU aims to enhance efficiency, accountability, and legal certainty. With the latest regulations, the role of PJPK becomes clearer, accelerating sustainable infrastructure projects and creating a more conducive investment environment for the private sector.

Thrifty Harianja; Elfi Amir; Dian Anggraini Purwaningtyas

WISSEN : Jurnal Ilmu Sosial dan Humaniora 2025 Asosiasi Peneliti Dan Pengajar Ilmu Sosial Indonesia

I Gusti Ngurah Rai International Airport – Bali is one of the airports with the busiest flight traffic in Indonesia, for both domestic and international routes. The high intensity of operational activities on the airside demands optimal management of all supporting elements, one of which is Ground Support Equipment (GSE). GSE plays a vital role in supporting aircraft movements and handling baggage, cargo, and passengers. Therefore, the provision of well-organized Equipment Parking Area (EPA) facilities in the Make Up and Break Down areas is crucial to ensure smooth and safe operations on the apron. This paper aims to examine the effectiveness of EPA provision and management in supporting GSE work efficiency, while identifying challenges and providing solutions to various emerging problems. The method used is a descriptive qualitative approach through direct observation, field documentation, and analysis of the actual layout compared to the provisions of the Directorate General of Civil Aviation Regulation No. PR 21 of 2023 concerning Technical and Operational Standards for Civil Aviation Safety Regulations. This research also complements EPA management practices at other airports in Indonesia, to provide a constructive comparative perspective. The study results indicate that the current management of the EPA at I Gusti Ngurah Rai Airport is not optimal. The main problems identified include irregular parking of GSE vehicles, the absence of zoning based on vehicle type, minimal markings, and a weak monitoring system due to limited personnel. As a result, congestion often occurs on GSE operational routes, which can disrupt the smooth operation of ground handling services. Based on these findings, proposed improvements include redesigning the EPA layout based on vehicle classification, installing signs and vehicle flow maps in strategic areas, and implementing an integrated technology-based monitoring system such as CCTV and digital access control.

Fiqi Nurman Gazali; Sri Kamariyah; Ika Devy Pramudiana; Kristyan Dwijosusilo

WISSEN : Jurnal Ilmu Sosial dan Humaniora 2025 Asosiasi Peneliti Dan Pengajar Ilmu Sosial Indonesia

This research aims to determine the effectiveness of the policy for implementing recess activities for council members in accommodating the aspirations of the community in East Java Province, based on the perspective of effectiveness theory. The recess is a formal mechanism designed to bring the legislature closer to the community in order to absorb input and hopes that can be integrated into the legislative and budgeting process. This study identified four main aspects of effectiveness: goal achievement, efficiency, relevance, and policy impact. Using qualitative research analysis and data collected through in-depth interviews, observation, and document analysis. The research results show that even though research is an important means for the community to convey needs, its implementation still faces obstacles, such as violations of follow-up to aspirations that have been received and a mismatch between community priorities and the development programs being implemented. This research provides encouragement for follow-up mechanisms and increasing legislative capacity in managing community aspirations so that res activities are more effective and relevant in supporting development at the regional level.

Engla Pabuser; Zulhendra Zulhendra; Syafrijon Syafrijon; Resmidarni Resmidarni

Merkurius : Jurnal Riset Sistem Informasi dan Teknik Informatika 2025 Asosiasi Riset Teknik Elektro dan Informatika Indonesia

The attendance system is an important aspect of personnel management that affects the effectiveness and efficiency of an institution's operations. Puskesmas Tarusan in Pesisir Selatan Regency still uses a manual attendance system that is vulnerable to data inaccuracies, real-time tracking difficulties, and potential fraud such as leaving attendance. To overcome this problem, this research aims to design a geolocation-based attendance application that can improve the accuracy of employee attendance recording and reduce the potential for abuse of the attendance system. This application uses a GPS-based geolocation method that allows attendance recording to only be done at a predetermined work location. By utilising this technology, attendance recording becomes more accurate, transparent, and can be monitored in real-time. This application was developed using the Unified Modelling Language (UML) approach for system design and using mobile-based technology to be easily accessed by employees. The test results show that this system is able to improve the accuracy of recording employee attendance and reduce the potential for fraud in attendance. In addition, this application provides convenience for management in monitoring employee attendance efficiently. With the implementation of this system, it is expected that Puskesmas Tarusan can improve transparency, accountability, and effectiveness in personnel management.

Safrial Safrial

Bridge : Jurnal Publikasi Sistem Informasi dan Telekomunikasi 2025 Asosiasi Profesi Telekomunikasi Dan Informatika Indonesia

Informatics systems have an important role in improving the effectiveness of the learning process in schools. This study aims to analyze the effect of the application of informatics systems on the quality of learning. The research method used is an experimental study with a quantitative approach. Data were collected through observation, interviews, and questionnaires given to students and teachers. The results of the study indicate that the use of informatics systems, such as e-learning and technology-based academic management, can improve the efficiency of school administration and facilitate student access to learning materials. These findings indicate the importance of technology integration in the world of education.  

Ni Luh Riyani Artha Saputri; Hodi Hodi

Jurnal Penelitian Manajemen dan Inovasi Riset 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Manajemen Kewirausahaan dan Bisnis Indonesia

The success of operational management at an airport is highly dependent on the performance and discipline of the Apron Movement Control (AMC) officers (Nurifi, 2024). AMC officers are required to be able to carry out high discipline, considering the many safety procedures that must be followed in order to avoid potential risks and incidents, because this affects the effectiveness of work and also the efficiency of airport officers, namely Apron Movement Control (AMC). The purpose of this study was to determine whether there is an influence of work discipline on the effectiveness of the work of Apron Movement Control (AMC) officers at Soekarno-Hatta International Airport and how much influence it has. This study uses a quantitative approach. The location of the research was carried out at Soekarno-Hatta International Airport, Benda District, Tangerang City and Kosambi, Tangerang, Banten. With a research period of August 2024 to February 2025. In this study, all Apron Movement Control (AMC) officers at Terminal 3 of Soekarno-Hatta International Airport, totaling 19 people, will be used as respondents by filling out the questionnaire provided. Based on the results of the research and analysis that have been conducted, it can be concluded that work discipline has a significant influence with a contribution of 75.9%. Meanwhile, the remaining 24.1% is influenced by other factors that were not analyzed in this study. This influence is proven by the coefficient of determination (R²) value of 0.759, which shows that work discipline contributes 75.9% to the effectiveness of the Apron Movement Control (AMC) officers at Soekarno-Hatta International Airport.

Wena Kusharyanti; Ika Devy Pramudiana; Eny Haryati

Jurnal Hukum, Administrasi Publik dan Negara 2025 Asosiasi Peneliti Dan Pengajar Ilmu Sosial Indonesia

This study aims to describe and analyze: the effectiveness of the implementation of the Revenue and Expenditure Budget policy and the implications of the implementation of the Regional Budget and Expenditure policy in Lumajang Regency. The data analysis technique uses the technique developed by McNabb (2002), namely Grouping the data according to key constructs, Identifying bases for interpretation, Developing generalizations from the data, Testing Alternative interpretations and Forming and/or refining generalizable theory from case study. The results of the study show that regional financial policies in Lumajang Regency, especially the policy of increasing Regional Original Revenue (PAD), are inseparable from the Central Government's policies in the framework of financial relations between the Central and Regional Governments. Meanwhile, the Lumajang Regency Government's policies to increase Regional Original Revenue (PAD/Pendapatan Asli Daerah) include: Digitalization to increase the efficiency and transparency of financial management, Adjustment of regional taxes and levies, Re-collection of taxpayers, Cooperation with the private sector and NGOs in the management and collection of regional taxes and Improvement of regional tax management management. The model of the implementation of the Regional Original Revenue (PAD) policy implementation model in Lumajang Regency is Top Down. The Government of Lumajang Regency, East Java is committed to continuing to encourage an increase in Regional Original Revenue (PAD). The contribution of Lumajang Regency's PAD in 2024 compared to the APBD (Anggaran Pendapatan Belanja Daeerah) structure only reaches 16 percent, so that to meet the needs of the expenditure budget in the APBD budgeting structure, it still depends on transfer funds, To reduce dependence on transfer funds, the government is optimizing regional tax revenues, especially from the Rural and Urban Land and Building Tax (PBB-P2). The implication is that to increase regional tax and levy revenues, efforts are needed to increase production and business capacity in the regions. Increasing production capacity and business activities is an important factor to increase regional tax and levy revenues. In addition, it is also necessary to increase the capacity of regional tax administration as one of the requirements to increase tax capacity and effort in the regions (taxable capacity and tax effort).

Gita Yolanda; Emilianus Eo Kutu Goo; Maria Modesta Missi Mone

International Journal of Economic, Social and Development Sciences 2025 International Forum of Researchers and Lecturers

The implementation of the Elektronik Barang Milik Daerah (e-BMD) system is crucial for improving the management and financial reporting of regional government assets. This study examines the effectiveness of e-BMD at the Badan Pengelola Keuangan dan Aset Daerah (BPKAD) of Sikka Regency in preparing financial reports, particularly for fixed and current assets. Using qualitative methods, data were collected through interviews, observation, and document analysis. The results show that e-BMD significantly enhances efficiency, accuracy, and accountability in asset management, although technical and resource limitations remain challenges. Recommendations include training enhancement and system optimization to improve performance.

Ni Nyoman Tri Wahyuni; I B Putra Yogi Smara; Putu Adi Arya Wardana

Jurnal Insan Pendidikan dan Sosial Humaniora 2025 International Forum of Researchers and Lecturers

This study aims to analyze the financial performance of CV Yanidilla Adilindo by using financial ratios, including liquidity, solvency, profitability, and activity ratios. The data used in this research consists of the company's financial statements for the last two years, including the income statement, balance sheet, and cash flow statement. Through the analysis of financial ratios, this study seeks to assess the effectiveness and efficiency of the company’s financial resource management and provide an overview of its strengths and weaknesses in financial aspects. The findings indicate that the company experienced fluctuations in financial performance, with some ratios showing improvement, while others exhibited a decline that requires further attention. Based on these findings, it is recommended that the company improve liquidity management and optimize its financing structure to support future financial stability.

Nurul Alifiya; Ika Fijriya; Anwar Ihsan Hidayat; Fahmi Sabila Nugraha

JUREKSI (Journal of Islamic Economics and Finance) 2025 STIKes Ibnu Sina Ajibarang

Often, the quality of human life, whether individually, in groups, communities, or countries, becomes a benchmark for economic welfare. The purpose of this study is to determine the effectiveness of the DPLK Syariah Muamalat program in Cirebon Regency. In this study, a descriptive qualitative approach is used. This is to describe and explain certain phenomena, conditions, or events in the existing data. The results of the study show that DPLK Muamalat as a sharia-based pension fund management institution has high efficiency by investing in halal instruments such as sukuk, sharia stocks, and sharia deposits. The programs offered include individual and corporate pension funds with investment flexibility, management transparency, and digital-based services. The marketing strategy is focused on education and collaboration to increase public literacy about the importance of sharia pension funds. Despite facing the challenge of low public understanding, DPLK Muamalat has a great opportunity as the only sharia-based DPLK in Indonesia.

Tama Wirawan; Syaila Cendana Maharani

Shipping and Transport Management Journal 2025 Indonesian Maritime Researchers and Lecturers

The growing environmental concerns and regulatory pressures on the shipping industry have prompted a shift towards the integration of green shipping technologies in managing international freight. This research investigates the adoption and effectiveness of these technologies, focusing on their role in reducing emissions, improving fuel efficiency, and enhancing the sustainability of global logistics. The study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining qualitative interviews with industry experts and quantitative analysis of freight operations data. The findings suggest that while green shipping technologies offer significant environmental benefits, their widespread adoption is hindered by high initial costs and regulatory complexities. Despite these challenges, the integration of sustainable practices in international freight management presents a promising pathway for achieving long-term environmental goals and improving industry competitiveness. The study highlights the need for collaborative efforts between shipping companies, policymakers, and stakeholders to overcome barriers and facilitate the adoption of green shipping technologies.

Okta Bryan Yudi Pratama; Muhammad Virsa Irawan; Ardhan Ardiansyah Kawakibi

Jurnal Pengabdian Sosial 2025 Lembaga Pengembangan Kinerja Dosen

Food security and community economic empowerment are major challenges in many rural areas, including Sukolilo Village. This research aims to develop and analyze the effectiveness of an aquaponic system, a combination of hydroponics and fish farming, as an innovative sustainable solution. The methods used include observation, experimentation, and interviews with the local community. The results showed that the aquaponic system is able to increase agricultural productivity with better water use efficiency and provide economic benefits through crop diversification, namely vegetables and fish. In addition, the system is proven to be environmentally friendly as it utilizes organic waste from fish as plant nutrients, reduces the use of chemical fertilizers, and optimizes local resources. The implementation of the aquaponic system in Sukolilo Village not only improves food security but also opens up new business opportunities for the community, thus contributing to the improvement of local economic welfare. It is hoped that this model can be replicated in other areas as part of a sustainable agriculture-based economic development strategy.

Desak Gede Suasridewi; Fedianty Agustina; Sri Kamariyah; Widyawati Widyawati; Eny Haryati

International Journal of Social Science and Humanity 2025 Asosiasi Penelitian dan Pengajar Ilmu Sosial Indonesia

This study analyzes the transformation of public services in Surabaya City through the implementation of Digital Population Identity (IKD), focusing on efficiency, effectiveness, transparency, accountability, and public participation. Using a qualitative case study method, data were collected through interviews, observations, and document analysis from policymakers, policy implementers, and the community. The findings show a positive impact of IKD on service efficiency and effectiveness, but challenges remain, particularly related to digital literacy. Transparency has improved due to real-time information access. Accountability has increased through digital complaint features, though staff capacity needs enhancement. Public participation has risen. The study recommends enhancing socialization, digital literacy, technological infrastructure, and staff capacity to maximize the benefits of IKD.

Maulina Maulina; Bukman Lian; Mahasir Mahasir

International Journal of Multilingual Education and Applied Linguistics 2025 Asosiasi Periset Bahasa Sastra Indonesia

Governor's Regulation Number 35 of 2022 regulates the system and procedures for the disbursement of funds within the South Sumatra Provincial Government, including the Education Office. The implementation of this regulation aims to increase transparency, efficiency, and accountability in regional financial management. This study analyzes the extent to which these regulations have been implemented as well as the factors that affect their effectiveness. The research method used is qualitative descriptive with a case study approach at the South Sumatra Provincial Education Office. The results of the study show that the implementation of this regulation has had a positive impact in accelerating the process of disbursing funds and increasing budget supervision. However, there are still several obstacles, such as limited human resources who understand regulations and technical challenges in the financial administration system. Therefore, further training and improvement of financial system infrastructure are needed to optimize the implementation of this regulation.

Nazwa Nurfauziah; Mawar Mawar; Fal Harmonis; M Qudrat Nugraha

Studi Administrasi Publik dan ilmu Komunikasi 2025 Asosiasi Peneliti Dan Pengajar Ilmu Sosial Indonesia

Licensing is an important factor for investors when making an investment. To speed up and simplify the licensing process, the government created the Online Single Submission (OSS) system. In South Tangerang, the Department of Investment and One Stop Integrated Services (DPMPTSP) plays an important role in the coffee shop business licensing process. To open a coffee shop, a location permit, environmental permit, NIB and business trading permit through OSS are required. Obstacles in the licensing process often cause delays and difficulties for business actors. The aim of this research is to determine and analyze the effectiveness of applying for coffee shop business permits through Online Single Submission at the South Tangerang One Stop Integrated Services Investment Service. The method used in the research is a qualitative approach with descriptive research type. This research uses the theory of Thomas R. Dye (2013). The research results show that the indicators for setting clear goals have not been achieved optimally even though the goals of time efficiency and transparency of business permits through the OSS system are quite effective. In the results measurement indicators, positive results have been achieved, which can be seen from the success of OSS in increasing the number of NIBs by 10% from the previous year. Performance evaluation indicators are not optimal due to limited email, network and server constraints, apart from that the appearance and provisions of the OSS system also make it difficult for users to access the OSS system again. In the cost-benefit analysis indicator, it is quite efficient in reducing permit processing time and without any costs incurred. Contextual factor indicators provide a positive impact where the JOSS Program is a form of the South Tangerang government's commitment to assisting the community in licensing through the OSS system. The feedback and adjustment indicators have not been optimal in providing guidance and information to business actors, so there are still business actors who have not registered their business permits through this OSS system.

Asst. lecture .Hassan D Obaid

Jurnal Publikasi Ekonomi dan Akuntansi 2025 Asosiasi Riset Ekonomi dan Akuntansi Indonesia

This study examines the effective role played by corporate governance in promoting e-marketing strategies, through an applied study conducted on Al-Rasheed Bank - Palestine Street Branch. In light of the rapid developments in the digital field, organizations are increasingly relying on e-marketing tools to improve their performance, making it necessary to apply governance principles to ensure the highest levels of efficiency, transparency, and credibility. The study aims to illustrate how governance can contribute to improving the performance of e-marketing in financial institutions, With a focus on Al-Rasheed Bank as an applied model. The study seeks to achieve several objectives, including analyzing the impact of governance mechanisms on e-marketing strategies, and knowing the extent to which the application of governance is related to achieving institutional goals and improving marketing efficiency. It also aims to study how governance contributes to building a transparent and secure relationship between the organization and its customers, which enhances loyalty and expands the customer base. In addition, the study highlights the challenges that organizations may face in applying governance to e-marketing and proposes solutions to address them. The study showed that there is a strong relationship between corporate governance and e-marketing, as governance helps in defining the goals and vision of the organization, which ensures that e-marketing strategies are compatible with the general directions of the organization. Enhancing transparency and accountability also contributes to building customers' trust in the organization, which increases their positive interaction with its marketing strategies. Moreover, governance helps ensure compliance with legal and ethical standards, which enhances the organization's reputation in the market and reduces the legal risks it may face. The study relied on the descriptive and analytical approach to analyze the relationship between governance and e-marketing, with a focus on data related to Al-Rasheed Bank - Palestine Street Branch. A simple random sample of 50 employees from different departments within the bank was selected. Statistical analysis was also used to measure the impact of governance on the efficiency of e-marketing within the organization. The results of the study showed that 84% of employees believe that corporate governance plays a key role in the success of digital marketing campaigns, reflecting a broad awareness of the importance of regulatory frameworks and corporate policies in guiding digital marketing operations. 73% of employees also confirmed that there are clear governance policies within the bank, which enhances confidence in the corporate system. With regard to customer trust, 79% of employees indicated that governance contributes to improving the level of trust in the electronic services provided by the bank, while 73% of them believe that governance positively affects the process of strategic decision-making in e-marketing. Also, 71% of employees reported that there is an effective system to monitor the performance of digital marketing campaigns, which helps to evaluate performance and improve strategies based on the results achieved. However, the study noted that there are some challenges facing the implementation of governance in the field of e-marketing. 33% of employees indicated that there is a lack of regular training programs on governance practices, which may negatively affect the effectiveness of their implementation. 38% of respondents also showed weakness in the mechanisms for evaluating the effectiveness of governance in improving e-marketing. In addition, 45% of employees indicated that there are gaps in communication between the governance department and the e-marketing department, which calls for improving channels Communication to ensure the integration of efforts between different departments. Based on these results, the study provided a set of recommendations aimed at improving the application of governance in e-marketing. Among these recommendations is the need to organize training workshops to familiarize employees with governance practices and their importance in improving marketing performance. The study also recommended the use of key performance indicators (KPIs) to conduct periodic evaluations and improve marketing strategies based on the results of these evaluations. In addition, the study stressed the importance of strengthening coordination between governance and e-marketing departments to ensure the integration of efforts and achieve Better results. It also recommended updating governance policies to keep pace with developments in the field of e-marketing, in order to contribute to supporting innovation and creativity in digital marketing strategies. In conclusion, the study confirmed that corporate governance plays a vital role in improving the efficiency of e-marketing, which contributes to enhancing customer confidence, achieving regulatory compliance, and increasing the effectiveness of marketing campaigns in financial institutions, especially in Rasheed Bank. She also stressed the importance of developing periodic training and evaluation strategies to ensure the optimal application of governance principles, in a way that enhances the performance of institutions in the changing digital environment.

Titis Ari Wibowo; Agung Kwartama

Ocean Engineering : Jurnal Ilmu Teknik dan Teknologi Maritim 2025 Fakultas Teknik Universitas Maritim AMNI Semarang

The procedures for cargo ship clearance in and out at Weda Port, Central Halmahera, managed by PT Pelayaran Bahtera Diserindo, play a vital role in ensuring efficient port operations and regulatory compliance. The clearance-in process consists of several steps that cargo ships must complete before entering the port, including document verification, health inspections, and adherence to security protocols. On the other hand, the clearance-out process involves procedures that must be completed before a ship departs, such as submitting shipping documents and undergoing cargo inspections. This study aims to examine these procedures, identify the challenges faced, and propose recommendations to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of clearance processes at Weda Port. By utilizing the latest data and statistics, this research also emphasizes the significant role of PT Pelayaran Bahtera Diserindo in facilitating logistics operations in North Maluku. The findings are expected to provide a comprehensive understanding of the existing procedures and their impact on Indonesia's maritime industry.

Grace Maria Fitricia; Yadi Fakhruzein Terang Jaya

Faedah : Jurnal Hasil Kegiatan Pengabdian Masyarakat Indonesia 2025 FKIP, Universitas Palangka Raya

Human resources are one of the main factors determining the effectiveness and efficiency of an organization which results in the achievement of organizational goals as an important resource beside capital resources, technology and equipment. Human resources who can process the resources owned by the organization effectively and efficiently will be able to achieve organizational goals as expected and can survive in business competition. To get the best human resources, the role of leadership is really important. In this community service activity, socialization was held to manage human resources,especially human resources in MSMEs with a servant leadership style for the purpose to manage human resources by empowering them who work in MSMEs to be more empowered and produce better performance to achieve organizational’s goal.

Luju, Elisabet; Winarti, Thresia

Jurnal Projemen UNIPA 2025 Universitas Nusa Nipa Maumere

research with the title Analysis of Financial Performance in Langir Village in 2022 and 2023. The aim of this research is to determine the performance of the Langir Village Government for the 2022 and 2024 fiscal years based on the decentralization ratio, Independence Ratio, Dependency Ratio, and Expenditure Effectiveness Ratio. The analytical method used is a qualitative approach. The research results show that the financial performance of the Langir Village Government for the 2022 and 2023 budget years based on the Decentralization ratio is still very low, the financial independence ratio is still very low, the dependency ratio shows that the level of dependence on the central and provincial governments is still very high, while based on the efficiency ratio it is still less efficient. This is caused by delays in signing and spending is still greater than income.

M. Taufik Ar Rauf; Fitri Kurnianingsih; Firman Firman

RISOMA : Jurnal Riset Sosial Humaniora dan Pendidikan 2025 Asosiasi Ilmuwan Pendidikan, Sosial, dan Humaniora Indonesia

Garbage is a problem that often occurs everywhere. One example is in Tanjungpinang City with various types of waste problems, one of which is plastic waste. For this reason, it needs to be handled seriously. One of the measures that has been carried out by the Tanjungpinang City government regarding the handling of plastic waste is to create a Tanjungpinang Mayor regulation policy no. 14 of 2022 concerning reducing the use of plastic bags. This regulatory policy was implemented on July 7 2022 and the policy of this regulation has been in place for approximately 2 years now. However, the results of implementing this policy regulation are still not as expected, with the data that has been presented in the background proving that every year there is an increase and plastic waste is in second place among the number of types of waste that exist. For this reason, this research aims to evaluate all forms of activities in implementing this policy using a descriptive qualitative approach according to the evaluation theory of Abdulkahar Badjuri & Teguh Yuwono (2002) which consists of 4 indicators, namely: suitability evaluation, effectiveness evaluation, efficiency evaluation and meta evaluation. Based on this theory, this research hopes that in the future this problem can be resolved and that regulatory policies run as expected so as to produce the desired results.