Publication Search

79,575 articles from 739 journals · 2,111 citations tracked

Showing 261-280 of 388

Analytics

Rio Ferdinand Yofi; R. Hiru Muhammad

RISOMA : Jurnal Riset Sosial Humaniora dan Pendidikan 2024 Asosiasi Ilmuwan Pendidikan, Sosial, dan Humaniora Indonesia

Al-Hamidiyah Depok Islamic Foundation is one of the educational institutions that uses YouTube social media as a medium for disseminating information. The NGASUH (Ngaji Bersama Pengasuh) program premiered on March 14, 2022 until this thesis was made, it has reached 49 episodes. The obstacles faced such as technical constraints and the host cannot attend live broadcasts. This research aims to find out the process of making the NGASUH program through the YouTube social media of the Al-Hamidiyah Islamic Foundation as a means of disseminating Islamic information for students, teachers, employees at the Al-Hamidiyah Islamic Foundation and to find out what obstacles were faced during the process of making the NGASUH program through the YouTube social media of the Al-Hamidiyah Islamic Foundation. The research theory in this study is production theory which consists of pre-production, production, and post-production. This research methodology uses a qualitative approach with descriptive methods with data collection techniques are in-depth interviews. The pre-production of the NGASUH program is the initial stage in the event production process which involves planning, preparing, and organizing all the necessary aspects before the live broadcast is carried out. The production stage of a live program requires tight coordination, adaptability, and readiness to handle situations that may arise during the broadcast. The entire production team must work together to ensure the smooth running of the event and provide a good experience to the audience. The post-production phase of a live program is the phase after the live broadcast is completed, where the evaluation, processing, and distribution of the broadcast results are carried out. This stage is important to evaluate the quality of the broadcast, collect feedback, and conduct follow-ups based on the results of the broadcast such as storing the broadcast materials properly for future reference and archives.

Rezzy Febriola; Malta Nelisa

Journal of Student Research 2024 Pusat Riset dan Inovasi Nasional

The purpose of this research is to describe (1) the diversity of people's internet use in the Balai-Balai Kota Padang Panjang subdistrict, (2) the information literacy skills of the community in the Balai-Balai Kota Padang Panjang subdistrict, (3) the influence of internet use on the information literacy skills of the community in Padang Panjang City Hall sub-district. This research uses quantitative research with descriptive methods. The population in this study was the community in the Balai-Balai City District of Padang Panjang with sampling using simple random sampling. The main instrument used was a research questionnaire which had been tested for validity and reliability, the sample size was 98 people. The population in the study was the community in the Balai-Balai City District of Padang Panjang. Data collection techniques are questionnaire techniques and questionnaire data processing through editing and tabulation stages. The results of the research are: (1) The community's internet use has an average answer score of 3.21. This score is on an interval scale of 2.50 – 3.24, which means that the internet use of the Padang Panjang City Hall community is classified as good. This can be seen from the intensity, usefulness and effectiveness of internet use carried out well. (2) Public information literacy has an average answer score of 3.11. This score is on an interval scale of 2.50 – 3.24, which means that the information literacy of the Padang Panjang City Hall community is classified as good. This can be seen from information literacy skills in determining information needs, finding information, evaluating information and using information for certain purposes by understanding aspects that are considered good. (3) The influence of internet use on the information literacy skills of people in the Balai-Balai City District of Padang Panjang is strong. From the results of the SPSS regression test, a correlation coefficient value of R = 0.787 was obtained, meaning that internet users have a positive influence on information literacy skills. The higher the use of the internet, the higher the information literacy skills in the Balai-Balai City District of Padang Panjang.

Amira Salsabila Afra Sihombing; Kusmilawaty Kusmilawaty

JURNAL RISET AKUNTANSI 2024 Institut Teknologi dan Bisnis (ITB) Semarang

The aim of this research is to determine the passport making system at the TPI Tanjung Balai Asahan Class II Immigration Office. The approach used in this research is descriptive qualitative with data sources using primary data obtained through observation and interviews. The results of this research indicate that the passport making system at the TPI Tanjung Balai Class II Immigration office can be said to be not good. This can be seen from the many complaints from the public. Regarding that, not all people are allowed to register for a passport directly at the immigration office and it is only allowed for people aged 50 years and over. Another complaint made by the public to Customer Care is the difficulty of logging into the existing application system, which is only opened once a week, namely on Fridays at 18.00 WIB. Then another complaint is the long queue for processing online passport applications and the long passport processing process. Therefore, it can be recommended to increase the M-Passport registration schedule, provide information on using the system for making passports online so that problems do not occur, and improve the quality of passport making services so that the passport making process does not take a long time.

Andika Panji Hermawan; Leni Susanti; Emi Sita Eriana; Ghema Nusa Persada

Neptunus: Jurnal Ilmu Komputer Dan Teknologi Informasi 2024 Asosiasi Riset Teknik Elektro dan Informatika Indonesia

The absence of an application to assist in the scheduling of the Communication and Informatics department's duties at TVRI has resulted in ineffective schedule distribution, causing a TVRI staff member to receive two coverage schedules simultaneously, while others may not receive any schedule at all. The purpose of this final report is to create an Application for Coverage, Announcers, and Editorial Schedules at TVRI using the PHP programming language with the Laravel framework and MYSQL database, and designing its interface using Bootstrap. The issue faced by TVRI's Communication and Informatics Department (Diskominfo) is the operational data processing of broadcasting schedules using Microsoft Excel, which poses several challenges including insufficient data security, unorganized data storage making it difficult to search, and the risk of losing previously saved data, thereby slowing down TVRI's reporting process. This application comprises three User levels: admin, User, and TVRI head. The research adopts the Prototype development method to create the Coverage, Announcers, and Editorial Schedule Application at TVRI. Through the Prototype, the development team can quickly visualize the application's design and functionality, gather early User feedback, and address potential issues or design improvements before full implementation. The research outcome, in the form of the application, provides a concrete solution to the challenges of scheduling effectiveness at TVRI, enhancing efficiency, addressing data security concerns, ensuring organized data storage, and improving workflow speed.

Dwi Anindya Harimurti

Eksekusi: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum dan Administrasi Negara 2024 Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Administrasi (STIA) Yappi Makassar

This research is motivated by the development of information technology which is currently changing people's lifestyles. With the internet, it is easier to transact online, especially with online shopping applications. The online trading industry has had a rapid impact with the public shopping culture. The two problems found in this research are how the e-commerce legal arrangements in Indonesia and the legal consequences of not implementing the e-commerce industry in accordance with Law Number 7 of 2014 concerning Trade. The normative research method is a data collection technique in this research, by processing data sourced from the existing legal rules and related legal materials. From the results of this research, it was found that in the applicable law online trading, it is mandatory to hold permits, complete and accurate information for consumers. In this case, it is concluded that the e-commerce industry must pay close attention to legal regulations related to the provision of goods and services, lest consumers suffer losses due to the existence of the e-commerce industry, by sending inappropriate goods. It is likely that consumers will lose.    

Andan Hafsari Mukminati; Andina Elok Puri Maharani

The International Conference on Education, Social Sciences and Technology 2024 International Forum of Researchers and Lecturers

Problem/Background (GAP): Building Construction Permit is a permit granted by the City/Regency Government to building owners to modify, build new, reduce and maintain buildings in accordance with administrative requirements and technical requirements. In its implementation, the aim of the IMB is to create an orderly layout and layout that is in accordance with the land use designation so that it will create harmony and balance between the environment and the building. To optimize public services to the community in the licensing sector which utilizes advances in information technology, the Boyolali Regency Investment and One-Stop Integrated Services Service has used a regionally managed online service system known as PTSP Online. This online service system was only implemented in 2020, where previously the Construction Building Permit (IMB) processing service was still carried out manually or offline. With this site, it is hoped that the quality of IMB licensing services can be improved more quickly and effectively. Objective: The purpose of this research is to determine and analyze the implementation of online-based Building Permit service policies and to determine the obstacles that occur in online-based Building Permit services. Method: The research design used in this research is qualitative research using descriptive methods and a deductive approach. Data collection techniques use interviews and documentation. Then the data collected was analyzed using data reduction techniques, data presentation and drawing conclusions. Results/Findings: The results of this research indicate that the implementation of the online building permit service policy in Boyolali Regency, Central Java Province has not been optimal because there are still obstacles in implementing the policy such as lack of socialization and information about online IMB regulations, the technology used is not optimal, lack of a technical team In the field, there are still brokers in online IMB processing. Conclusion: Based on the research conducted, the author suggests to DPMPTSP Boyolali Regency to carry out scheduled socialization so that the community is able to understand existing policies, increase supervision so that brokering practices are minimized, carry out repairs and maintenance of network systems, and recruit a team of technical employees.

Alvi Nabilah; Salsabilla Ronardi; Queen Shakira Azzahra; Fitrah Maharani; Siti Rodiah

Jurnal Mutiara Ilmu Akuntansi (JUMIA) 2024 Pusat Riset dan Inovasi Nasional

This research aims to provide additional empirical evidence to understand whether accounting students' entrepreneurial interest is enhanced by e-commerce, entrepreneurship science, and accounting information systems. Quantitative research is used in this type of research. The data analysis technique used is Multiple Linear Regression. The data collection technique used by researchers is by distributing online questionnaires to 50 Accounting students class of 2021 Regular A, Faculty of Economics and Business, Muhammadiyah University of Riau and processing them using SPSS 26. The results of the research show that partially E-commerce and Accounting Information Systems do not have a significant effect on interest in entrepreneurship, while entrepreneurship knowledge has a significant effect on interest in entrepreneurship.    

Aji Priyambodo; Prihati Prihati

International Journal of Computer Technology and Science 2024 Asosiasi Riset Teknik Elektro dan Infomatika Indonesia

The rapid growth of cross-platform applications has significantly increased the volume and diversity of sensitive user data processed across heterogeneous and distributed environments. Personally identifiable information, device identifiers, behavioral data, and financial information are routinely collected to support personalization, analytics, and service optimization. While these practices enhance application functionality and user experience, they also introduce substantial privacy risks, including unauthorized data access, device fingerprint–based re-identification, cross-user data leakage, and large-scale data breaches. These risks are further amplified by distributed processing architectures and extensive third-party library integrations commonly used in modern cross-platform systems. This study aims to systematically analyze privacy issues in cross-platform applications by examining the types of sensitive data involved, identifying dominant privacy threats, and reviewing state-of-the-art privacy-preserving mitigation strategies. A systematic literature-based methodology was employed, focusing on recent Scopus-indexed journal articles, conference papers, and book chapters. The analysis synthesizes findings using thematic categorization and a conceptual research framework that maps sensitive data sources to privacy threats and corresponding mitigation mechanisms. The results indicate that privacy risks in cross-platform applications originate not only from external attacks but also from internal architectural weaknesses, such as flawed authorization logic and excessive data sharing across system components. Privacy-preserving techniques including differential privacy, federated learning, blockchain-based data governance, secure multi-party computation, and fine-grained access control mechanisms are shown to provide stronger privacy guarantees compared to conventional centralized approaches. However, these techniques also present trade-offs related to system complexity and performance. Overall, the study highlights the importance of adopting a multi-layered, privacy-by-design approach to ensure sustainable, trustworthy, and regulation-compliant cross-platform application development.

Irma Yanti; Darman Darman; Munawarah Munawarah; Wiri Wirastuti 

Maslahah : Jurnal Manajemen dan Ekonomi Syariah 2024 STAI YPIQ BAUBAU, SULAWESI TENGGARA

This research discusses the role of SI APIK application in improving the quality of CV Rapoviaka Simple's financial statements. SI APIK, as an integrated financial information system, is designed to simplify the process of recording, processing, and reporting company finances. The application is designed to simplify the financial recording process, reducing the potential for human error. This study aims to determine the role of the SIAPIK application in improving the quality of financial statements. The type of research used is descriptive qualitative research using primary data. Interviews and observations are a reference in this study to explain a measure of the quality of financial statements. The results of this study indicate that the SI APIK application has succeeded in increasing the efficiency of preparing financial reports. SI APIK also helps in managing financial data in real-time allowing companies to respond to market changes faster.  

Sri Rani; Arini Aha Pekuwali; Trisari Dewi Novyanti Bertha Mira

JURNAL PENELITIAN SISTEM INFORMASI 2024 Institut Teknologi dan Bisnis (ITB) Semarang

The development of technology as a medium for delivering information has provided great benefits for business owners, including in the field of wedding equipment rental. However, Nellysalon Waingapu in Waingapu faces several problems, such as a lack of complete information in promotional media and manual rental records. To overcome this problem, the development of a web-based Wedding Equipment Rental Information System is proposed. This system allows customers to get detailed information about rental packages, prices and status of rented items. Apart from that, this system also helps business owners in storing and processing rental data quickly and accurately. The development method used is the waterfall model from SDLC. Test results show that this system is well received by users, with an average score of 70.6 in the SUS test. Thus, the Wedding Equipment Rental System at Nellysalon Waingapu is suitable for use by system users..

Sika Noviani; Apriyani; Syamsul Hidayat

Student Research Journal 2024 Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Administrasi (STIA) Yappi Makassar

Based on data released in 2023, the human need to use sunscreen is very important for every human being. Research results show that sunscreen is very important for teenage skin, because at the age of teenagers, facial skin has begun to be exposed to sunlight due to high levels of outdoor activity. However, choosing It is very important to do good sunscreen so that the skin does not become more problematic due to the chemicals contained in sunscreen products. Therefore, this research aims to find out how important it is to use sunscreen among semester 1 3 5 students of Bina Bangsa University. Based on that introduction, theoretical studies and data processing as well as discussions that have been carried out in the previous chapter. The main goal of this technique is to extract relevant information, identify patterns or trends, and gain a better understanding of the phenomena represented by the data. This quantitative research data analysis technique uses the help of Excel and SPSS. sunscreen products, that not using sunscreen can cause many dangers to skin health, such as premature aging, the appearance of blackheads and skin damage and cancer and can trigger the appearance of new lesions in several types of skin diseases.

Resya Dwi Marselina; Salsabilla Puspa Rianty; Sawitri Nurhayati; Noval Robani Hardiansyah; Winda Aisyah

Riset Ilmu Manajemen Bisnis dan Akuntansi 2024 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Manajemen Kewirausahaan dan Bisnis Indonesia

This research was conducted to find out how the marketing strategy carried out by CV. Ciwidey food and what CV does. Ciwidey Food in developing its business network. Observation and interviews were the data collection techniques used in this study. The analysis method used is a descriptive qualitative analysis method, namely by collecting, processing and presenting data obtained when conducting research so that complete information is obtained about what is researched. Based on the results of the analysis that has been done, it can be concluded that the strategy in building a CV. Ciwidey Food can be done by expanding promotions through social media such as TikTok, Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp. CV. Ciwidey Food builds a business network with expedition services in marketing its products. Expedition business networks can provide great benefits to CVs. Ciwidey Food by having a partnership with the network CV. Ciwidey Food can expand the distribution range of their products, such as being sent out of town and even abroad.

Ahmad Ashifuddin Aqham

JURNAL PENELITIAN SISTEM INFORMASI 2024 Institut Teknologi dan Bisnis (ITB) Semarang

The need for technology is greatly needed by various groups, both in the world of education, in companies and government agencies as a solution to these problems. One of them is implementing an accounting information system for inputting, processing or reporting accounting in the company. This application can produce data processing quickly and accurately. This certainly saves a lot of time and also reduces errors that occur when work is done manually. Likewise with cooperatives, cooperatives also need to use an accounting information system to make their work faster and more accurate. The activities carried out at Primkopti "Harum" Kendal Regency are in the field of savings and loans. The process of recording loans at Primkopti "Harum" becomes ineffective and there is a risk of errors in information that is not accurate and fast, because the recording process is repetitive. For reporting, we still use Ms. Excel, which still requires data processing first from the books, both loans and installments, so there are often delays in submitting reports to management. Therefore, with a computerized system that can process customer data, collateral data, journals, loan and installment transactions, and also reports that will be made by Primkopti "Harum" will be valid, especially in calculating installment interest costs, using Macromedia Dreamweaver software 8, PHP programming language, and MySQL database. The results of the programming created help reduce errors in data entered, errors in interest calculations, financial reports are produced more quickly and effectiveness and efficiency can be achieved.

Ardiansyah, Fachrizal; Wahyu, Ahmad

Jurnal Mahasiswa Kreatif 2024 International Forum of Researchers and Lecturers

ABSTRACT. This article discussess the closeness between random object service gacha(lootbox) with gambling which raises concerns about plunging players, especially children. This article aims to see the closeness between gacha system and gambling, made by the method of literature study, namely through recording, literature review and data processing. The data taken is seen from the current situation and then collects information about the topic being discussed. The similarity between gacha and gambling systems shows the closeness between, players who paid for gacha can be said to be gambling. Meanwhile, players who don’t pay and just have fun are not decisive called a gambler. However, there needs to be a deeper analysis of this matter.   Keyword : Game, Gacha, and Gambling   Abstrak. Artikel ini membahas kedekatan antara layanan benda acak gacha(lootbox) dengan judi yang memunculkan kekhawatiran akan menjerumuskan pemain terutama anak – anak. Artikel ini bertujuan untuk melihat kedekatan antara sistem gacha dengan judi, dibuat dengan metode studi literatur yakni melalui pencatatan, kajian Pustaka dan pengolahan data. Data yang diambil dilihat dari keadaan yang sedang terjadi saat ini kemudian mengumpulkan informasi mengenai topik yang dibahas. Kesamaan antara sistem gacha dan judi menunjukkan kedekatan antara keduanya, pemain yang membayar untuk melakukan gacha dapat dianggap sebagai perjudian. Sedangkan pemain yang tidak membayar dan hanya bersenang – senang tidak mutlak disebut sebagai penjudi. Meskipun begitu, perlu adanya analisis lebih dalam mengenai hal tersebut.   Kata Kunci : Game, Gacha, dan Judi

Habib Fajar Aditya; Rayhan Gunaningrat

Global Leadership Organizational Research in Management 2024 STIKes Ibnu Sina Ajibarang

Consumers want to be respected throughout the purchasing process until after sales. Service quality is something that is important for the industry to pay attention to because it has an impact on consumers who want to shop. Ease of use, such as ease of navigation and collection of information, makes it easier for consumers to make purchases. Price determines consumers' purchasing decisions. Price determines how consumers search for products and compare prices before making a final decision. This research uses a quantitative approach in its research methodology. The information used in this research is essential information. Main information was collected through an online questionnaire distributed to Shopee consumers in the Greater Solo area via Google Form and distributed via social media platforms. The survey contains questions that are assessed using a Likert Scale of 1 to 5. Data processing uses the SPSS version 25 program. To expect a questionnaire that may not be completed, an example of a decision size is 108 respondents in this review. The results of the findings can be summarized as follows: service quality has a significance value of 0.000<0.05, ease of use has a significance value of 0.042<0.05, and product price has a significance value of 0.000<0.05. As a result, all variables have a significant impact significant impact on consumers' decisions regarding which products to buy. There is a significant impact on the quality of service, ease of use, and price of products available on the Shopee platform.

Yoga Anunggita; Tranggono Tranggono

Konstruksi: Publikasi Ilmu Teknik, Perencanaan Tata Ruang dan Teknik Sipil 2024 Asosiasi Riset Ilmu Teknik Indonesia

In measuring the corporate performance of PT X in the third quarter period, it has not been achieved optimally. This non-achievement is caused by several factors including projects from several corporate divisions in the production section that have not been completed within 1 year, the realization of the Company's Work Plan and Budget Year 2023 which is not optimal, and performance management by each corporate leader that is not optimal. Therefore, it is necessary to measure the company's corporate performance using the Key Performance Indicator method to determine performance measures in Quarter III. The research conducted uses information obtained from observations and data sources directly from the company. Then data processing using the Key Performance Indicator method to determine the achievement of the company's corporate performance. From the results of the achievement of each indicator, the total score of the company's corporate Key Performance Indicator in the third quarter of 2023 was 46.45%. For the Key Performance Indicator target based on the Company's Work Plan and Budget of 100%. Therefore, the achievement of the realization of the Key Performance Indicator score on the company's corporate performance has not met the target in the Company's Work Plan and Budget for 2023. So it is necessary to accelerate the realization of indicators that have not met the achievement of performance based on the Company's Work Plan and Budget Year 2023.                                                                                                    

Siti Izzati Sarah; Yahfizham Yahfizham

Konstanta : Jurnal Matematika dan Ilmu Pengetahuan Alam 2024 International Forum of Researchers and Lecturers

Big data processing has become an important aspect of computer science and various industries in the digital age. Efficient and timely programming algorithms play a central role in addressing the challenges presented by big data. This journal focuses on various optimization methods and techniques that can be applied in the development of programming algorithms for processing big data. Supporting and relevant references are used to illustrate the concepts and techniques presented in this paper. Discussions include parallel methods, data compression, indexing, divide and conquer strategies, and greedy algorithm approaches. Case studies on the implementation of fast sorting algorithms in the context of big data processing are also presented. The understanding and application of these optimization methods are important in maximizing the efficiency and performance of programming algorithms in dealing with big data, and they play a key role in the development of relevant information technology solutions.  

Rizka Khoirotun Nisaa; Salsabila Maulidya Supriadi Bahrim; Irda Agustin Kustiwi

Jurnal Mutiara Ilmu Akuntansi (JUMIA) 2024 Pusat Riset dan Inovasi Nasional

This article discusses the impact of digital technology on the transformation of internal audit and its implications for the treatment of financial reports. As technology advances, companies are adopting digital solutions to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of their internal audit processes. This transformation not only includes the use of new tools and technologies, but also changes the paradigm and methodology of internal audit work. Digital technology provides greater capabilities in collecting, analyzing and understanding data in real-time. Internal audit can leverage advanced analytics technology, artificial intelligence, and natural language processing to identify risks, detect anomalies, and provide deeper insights into a company's finances. With the adoption of digital technology, internal audit transformation can increase audit accuracy and thoroughness, reduce the risk of human error, and enable fraud identification more effectively. In addition, technology also facilitates the implementation of more proactive and adaptive risk-based audit practices, allowing internal audit to focus on the most critical areas and provide significant added value. However, this transformation also brings new challenges, including the need to develop new skills among auditors, manage information security risks, and ensure compliance with regulations related to data privacy and security. This article details effective implementation strategies, as well as providing views on how organizations can optimize the potential of digital technology to improve the quality of financial reporting treatment. Thus, this article aims to provide in-depth insight into the role of digital technology in the transformation of internal audit and its impact on the treatment of financial statements, identify the associated benefits and challenges, and provide guidance for companies wishing to adopt such technology effectively.

Toyipur Toyipur

Proceeding International Conference Of Innovation Science, Technology, Education, Children And Health 2023 Program Studi DIII Rekam Medis dan Informasi Kesehatan

This research is a needs assessment evaluation which aims to determine the effectiveness of the information technology-based learning program, namely online or online learning to emphasize the difference between the desired or should be or expected conditions (what is) or real / real conditions. in the Covid-19 era with truth and validity data, facts, or information. The research was conducted using mixed methods research or a combination of qualitative and quantitative research in one study with evaluation of "needs assessment", data analysis with descriptive statistics. Collecting data using observation instruments, documentation and questionnaires, distributing questionnaires by means of random or random techniques, data processing refers to the Likert scale with the SPSS program computer The research results from the data on the achievement of class based learning process performance and information technology in 2020 15.78%, while from the research results; the highest score was 88, the lowest score was 50, the mean 66.47, the standard deviation was 11,780, the score scale ranges from 50 to 88, meaning that The effectiveness of online informatics technology-based learning methods in the Covid-19 era can be categorized as unsuccessful according to predetermined learning outcomes    

Toyipur Toyipur

Proceeding International Conference Of Innovation Science, Technology, Education, Children And Health 2023 Program Studi DIII Rekam Medis dan Informasi Kesehatan

This research is a needs assessment evaluation which aims to determine the effectiveness of the information technology-based learning program, namely online or online learning to emphasize the difference between the desired or should be or expected conditions (what is) or real / real conditions. in the Covid-19 era with truth and validity data, facts, or information. The research was conducted using mixed methods research or a combination of qualitative and quantitative research in one study with evaluation of "needs assessment", data analysis with descriptive statistics. Collecting data using observation instruments, documentation and questionnaires, distributing questionnaires by means of random or random techniques, data processing refers to the Likert scale with the SPSS program computer The research results from the data on the achievement of class based learning process performance and information technology in 2020 15.78%, while from the research results; the highest score was 88, the lowest score was 50, the mean 66.47, the standard deviation was 11,780, the score scale ranges from 50 to 88, meaning that The effectiveness of online informatics technology-based learning methods in the Covid-19 era can be categorized as unsuccessful according to predetermined learning outcomes